Archive for February 8th, 2010

h1

Georgia electric consumers want competition to help protect against higher prices, just like they have for natural gas

February 8, 2010

Michael Giberson

From WTVM-9:

Latrese Brown, a Cusseta [Georgia] resident, gathered a group of people who believe Sumter EMC is ripping them off. “Not only mine but my entire community light bills are outrageous high, they’re more than our mortgages, more than our rent, more than our car note,” complains Brown.

… The citizens of Cusseta went to their county commissioners Tuesday night and asked them to consider bringing in another company.

“You should be able to choose who you’re with, we choose our gas company, we should be able to choose who provides our lights to us because we want to choose our customer service.”

Notice what she said? “We choose our gas company, we should be able to choose who provides our lights …” Georgia is, I think, unique in allowing competitive retail natural gas suppliers to operate. Consumer Latrese Brown has experienced a competitive retail gas market and a regulated monopoly electric utility service, and she concluded she’d like to give competitive retail electricity a try, too.

Greg Crowder, vice president of marketing and administration at Sumter EMC says it’s not Sumter Electric calling the shots. He argues they have not increased rates and that the electric service act decided territories for electric companies.

“It was done to keep from duplicating efforts, two utilities running down the same road to serve the same customer then that’s inefficient,” says Crowder.

Of course Georgia is not overrun with multiple natural gas pipes running down the same road. A single natural gas pipeline company manages the distribution pipeline and provides delivery service.  Separately, about 15 or so competing retail natural gas suppliers offer consumers a variety of fixed-price or variable-price contract offerings and other terms.

It is not too complicated to have a single wire running down the street and yet multiple retailers delivering power over that single wire.

… And, the cause for the high bills is nothing more than the heaters reaction to the extreme temperatures, “the heating load is what caused the high bills, we’ve seen it before.”

The proximate cause of the unexpectedly high bills was the much cooler than normal weather experienced this winter.  Nothing unusual about occasionally experiences unusually cold weather. What seemed noteworthy about the news story was that consumers facing unexpectedly high bills were not demanding regulators take direct action to reduce electric rates.  Rather, they sought protection through competition, just like they already enjoy for retail natural gas prices.

h1

Tres Amigas wants to take cheap electric power away from hard-working Texas families

February 8, 2010

Michael Giberson

I spent the middle of last week in Austin at the University of Texas-Law conference on wind, solar and geothermal energy law, and as a side bonus got to hear some informal, Austin-based commentary on the Tres Amigas proposal to interconnect the Eastern, Western, and Texas electric grids. It will give you some idea of the thinking in the state capital that I heard the term “Dos Amigas” used more than a few times.

During the pre-conference “fundamentals” discussion, in response to a question that asked whether stronger transmission links to other states would help accommodate added growth in Texas wind power, a current member of the Public Utility Commission of Texas arose from the audience, climbed onto the dais, and took the microphone to say, among other things, “ERCOT is just fine the way it is.” The other main point of his comment was to suggest that the Southwest Power Pool, which has long covered the wind resource rich Texas Panhandle (with relatively weak links elsewhere, but a plan to beef up those links), would ably serve to sell the wind resource out of state while not compromising ERCOT’s jurisdictional status with respect to the feds.

Later in the conference a speaker offered a Texas policymaker’s view: ERCOT has its well-regarded CREZ plan to spend $5 billion on transmission enhancements primarily intended to allow wind generation in far west Texas, central west Texas, and the Texas panhandle to be delivered downstate to consumers in the Dallas, Houston, Austin, and San Antonio regions. If those lines link to Tres Amigas, then the prospect arises that consumers elsewhere will – in effect – “drink our milkshake.” Texas policymakers don’t want other consumers to drink our milkshake, especially after ERCOT consumers spend $5 billion to build there own transmission “straw” into the Panhandle region.  (Yeah, I watched “There Will Be Blood” a week or so ago, hence the milkshake and straw references. The presenter did not use this language.)

Peter Behr, writing for ClimateWire, has a more journalistic report on the debate over Tres Amigas. Behr reports that Occidental Petroleum – a large power consumer within the ERCOT region – has actively opposed the Tres Amigas project in filings at FERC, as has the Texas Industrial Energy Consumers. I haven’t read their filings, but apparently they believe ERCOT power prices will be higher on average with Tres Amigas than without, and as consumers they prefer lower prices.

In my opinion, however, they are more likely to get slightly lower (and somewhat less volatile) prices with better links to the rest of the grid.  That’s the way market expansion usually works.

Tres Amigas posts its FERC filings and related documents on its website. Here are links to a couple of the opposing views filed at FERC.  The “Supplemental Protest of Occidental…” includes the expert witness testimony that Behr discusses in his story:

Not all Texas policymakers oppose Tres Amigas. Member of Congress Randy Neugebauer (R-TX) sent FERC a letter indicating the project would encourage investment in renewable power and urging the Commission to give the project a “fair and deliberate view.”  And, as the ClimateWire story suggests, developers aiming to exploit the extensive power generation potential of the region are strongly behind the project.

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 41 other followers